THE SHORT ANSWER
To use the Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii) bidding safe harbor for a GIC or a yield-restricted defeasance escrow investment, the provider or GIC obligor certifies the administrative costs it pays or expects to pay to third parties, and the issuer keeps that certification and the bid records with the bond documents until 3 years after the last outstanding bond is redeemed; the Bidding Agent's certificate is market practice.
After a bond-proceeds investment is competitively bid, two certifications make up the closing set: the provider's certification of administrative costs, which Treasury Regulation §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(D) makes a condition of the fair-market-value safe harbor for GICs and yield-restricted defeasance escrow investments, and the Bidding Agent's certificate, which market practice adds.
Alongside them sits the bid record that, to use the same safe harbor, the issuer keeps with the bond documents until 3 years after the last outstanding bond is redeemed (Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(E)).
This page takes each deliverable in turn within the guide to competitive bidding, where the steps that produce these documents are covered.
What does the provider certification cover?
The provider of the investment, or the obligor on the guaranteed investment contract, must certify the administrative costs that it pays, or expects to pay if any, to third parties in connection with supplying the investment (Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(D)).
The certification is the fourth of five conditions in the bidding safe harbor, which treats the purchase price of a GIC, or of an investment purchased for a yield-restricted defeasance escrow, as fair market value on the purchase date when every condition is met (Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)).
The provider's representations start earlier, at the bid itself: the bid specifications must state that submitting a bid is a representation that the provider did not consult with any other potential provider about its bid, that the bid was set without regard to other agreements with the issuer or anyone else, and that it is not a courtesy bid (Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(A)(3)).
The anatomy of those specifications, from the rate quotation form to credit and collateral terms, is on the bid specifications page.
The certifications in the closing set, and where each comes from, are:
| Certification | Who gives it | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Provider certification of administrative costs | The provider of the investments, or the GIC obligor | Administrative costs paid or expected to be paid to third parties in connection with supplying the investment (Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(D)) |
| Bidding Agent certificate | The firm that ran the solicitation | Market practice at closing; the safe harbor's conditions are the provider certification and the issuer's records, not an agent certificate |
Do state laws add certification conditions?
Texas conditions a GIC's qualification under its own statute on five items: specific authorization in the bond-authorizing order, ordinance or resolution; bids from at least three separate providers with no material financial interest in the bonds; purchase of the highest-yielding qualifying bid; a price reflecting the reasonably expected drawdown schedule; and the provider's certification of the administrative costs reasonably expected to be paid to third parties (Tex. Gov't Code §2256.015(c)).
That is a state-law condition, separate from the federal Treas. Reg. §1.148-5 safe harbor, and the rest of Texas's bond-proceeds investment rules are on the Texas page.
Do SLGS purchases carry certifications?
Certifications also arise outside a competitive bid: a SLGS subscriber certifies yields, certifies that the term of the security is no longer than is reasonably necessary to accomplish the issuer's governmental purpose, and certifies to tell Treasury if eligibility ends (31 CFR 344.2(e)(1)–(4)).
An agent certification applies when a bank or other agent subscribes for the issuer, and the duration and eligibility certifications were added by Treasury's 2024 SLGS rule.
The mechanics of the program are on the SLGS page.
What is the Bidding Agent certificate?
The Bidding Agent certificate is the closing deliverable from the firm that ran the solicitation, and it is common market practice rather than a requirement written in Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii).
The safe harbor's own conditions for these documents are the provider certification of administrative costs and the issuer's retention of the bid record.
An advisor that signs a certificate works under the duty-of-care standard the MSRB sets for municipal advisors: the knowledge and expertise to give informed advice, reasonable inquiry into the relevant facts, and a reasonable basis for its advice and for representations in certificates the advisor signs.
The practice has a history in the SEC's bid-rigging cases: in the Banc of America Securities action, the SEC found that bidding agents received undisclosed gratuitous payments and kickbacks, and in the Wachovia action it charged Wachovia Bank with rigging at least 58 reinvestment transactions in 25 states and Puerto Rico, including bids won through "set-ups" in which the bidding agent deliberately obtained non-winning bids from other providers.
Both actions were settled without admissions, per standard SEC practice.
In mGIC's documentation and settlement service, the Bidding Agent and provider certifications are delivered to bond counsel, and the firm runs the process without selling an investment product: mGIC does not act as principal in the investments it evaluates, and as an SEC-registered municipal advisor it owes its municipal clients a fiduciary duty.
An issuer that wants the solicitation run on that basis can use mGIC as Bidding Agent.
What does bond counsel rely on?
Whether the delivered certificates and records support the tax conclusions for a given issue is bond counsel's determination, not the Bidding Agent's.
The MSRB glossary describes bond counsel as the attorney or firm, typically retained by the issuer, that gives an opinion that the bonds have been validly issued and, if tax exemption is intended, that they are tax-exempt bonds.
What does the enforcement record show?
The enforcement record shows what falsely certified compliance with the Treasury bidding rules looks like: per the Justice Department's brief in Heinz v. United States, the former UBS executives who rigged bids on municipal investment contracts conspired with counterparts at other banks and with a broker that gave UBS last looks, and they falsely certified compliance with Treasury regulations.
Peter Ghavami, Gary Heinz and Michael Welty were convicted of wire fraud and/or conspiracy to commit wire fraud, sentenced to 18, 27 and 16 months, fined $1 million, $400,000 and $300,000, and the Second Circuit affirmed.
On the civil side, the SEC found that Banc of America Securities won bids on 88 affected reinvestment instruments through last looks and set-ups, and its December 2010 settlement had BAS paying more than $36 million to the SEC and $101 million to other federal and state authorities.
Those cases are the backdrop against which the no-consultation representation in the bid specifications and the closing certifications are delivered.
How long are the certifications and bid records kept?
To use the safe harbor, the issuer retains the records the regulation names with the bond documents until 3 years after the last outstanding bond is redeemed (Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(E)(1)–(5)).
The records the regulation names are:
- the contract or purchase agreement,
- the receipt for the amount paid, with any administrative costs and the provider certification,
- each bid's submitter, time, date and result,
- the bid solicitation form, with an explanation of any deviations,
- and, for non-GIC purchases, the cost of the most efficient SLGS portfolio when bids were due.
GFOA's best practice on bond proceeds recommends keeping records for the required period, which it describes as typically the life of the bonds plus three years; that is GFOA's description, and the regulation's line for the bidding file is the 3-years-after-redemption rule above.
The bidding items slot into the transaction compliance file, and the wider post-closing duties are on the post-issuance compliance page.
The Bidding Agent keeps a separate file of its own: where the firm is a municipal advisor, SEC Rule 15Ba1-8 requires it to keep, among other records, all written communications relating to its municipal advisory activities and any document material to a recommendation or memorializing its basis, and those are the advisor's records rather than the issuer's tax-compliance records.
Final determinations about what an issue's certifications and records must contain belong to bond counsel and tax counsel.
To have an independent Bidding Agent run the solicitation and deliver the closing set, you can ask mGIC for a reinvestment review.
Frequently asked questions
Who delivers the certifications at closing?
The provider of the investment, or the GIC obligor, delivers the administrative-costs certification that Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(D) makes a condition of the bidding safe harbor. The Bidding Agent delivers its own certificate alongside it, and both go to bond counsel as part of documentation and settlement.
What administrative costs does the provider certification cover?
The costs the provider pays, or expects to pay if any, to third parties in connection with supplying the investment (Treas. Reg. §1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(D)). The regulation states the category, and the certification is the provider's own statement of those costs.
Does Texas require a provider certification for GICs?
Yes. Texas Government Code §2256.015(c)(5) requires the provider to certify the administrative costs reasonably expected to be paid to third parties, as one of five conditions for a Texas GIC. That state-law condition is separate from the federal bidding safe harbor.
What certifications come with a SLGS purchase?
A SLGS subscriber certifies yields, certifies that the term of the security is no longer than reasonably necessary for the governmental purpose, and certifies to tell Treasury if eligibility ends (31 CFR 344.2(e)(1)–(4)). The duration and eligibility certifications were added by Treasury's 2024 SLGS rule.
What does the MSRB duty-of-care rule require for certificates an advisor signs?
The MSRB's duty of care for municipal advisors requires the knowledge and expertise to give informed advice, reasonable inquiry into the relevant facts, and a reasonable basis for its advice and for representations in certificates the advisor signs.
Sources
- 26 CFR 1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)
- 26 CFR 1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(A)(3)
- 26 CFR 1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(D)
- 26 CFR 1.148-5(d)(6)(iii)(E)
- Texas Government Code §2256.015(c)
- MSRB Glossary of Municipal Securities Terms, 3rd ed. (Aug. 2013)
- SEC Press Release 2010-239
- SEC Litigation Release No. 22183
- Brief for the United States in Opposition, Heinz v. United States, No. 15-432
- GFOA, Investment and Management of Bond Proceeds
- eCFR 31 CFR 344.2(e)
- MSRB Rule G-42
- 17 CFR 240.15Ba1-8
This page is general educational information about municipal finance and federal and state rules as of the date shown. It is not legal, tax or investment advice, and it is not a recommendation about any particular investment. Product availability, legality and suitability depend on the issuer, jurisdiction, governing documents and transaction-specific facts. Final legal and tax determinations remain with the issuer's bond counsel, tax counsel and other advisors.